I read an interesting quote today about the emergent movement. Tony Jones said…
”[Doug Pagitt and I] talk affectionately about guys like Bill Hybels and Rick Warren because we’re now going through a lot of the criticism that they went through in the ‘80s when they were doing church in a high school gymnasium and taking the word ‘Baptist’ off their name. Had there been no ‘seeker movement,’ I think there would be no ‘emergent movement.’”
It got me thinking of all the critique I remember hearing about the Willow & Saddle-ites. I remember there being such a focus on their watering down the gospel, but now they are considered two powerhouse congregations in the nation. I find it interesting that two churches that were trying to ‘figure out’ how to be culturally relevant with an unchanging message back then are front-runners now. And more so, their senior pastors are highly respected and dynamic leaders.
There seems to be similar controversy about the Emergent movement today and I wonder if their attempt at relevance has caught the eye of skeptics and critics alike. I wonder if in years to come these emergent pioneers will be front-runners of the next generations of church. And I wonder if today’s big church leaders are okay with that?
QUIRKY: Another intriguing thought with the emergent critique is that many of those attacking its views of truth/theology are of the Calvinist camp. Calvinist would seem to believe that God is fully in control and His plans will not be thwarted. In addition, nothing ever takes God by surprise and everything is within His Sovereign hands. Well…
If that’s true, then why worry about ‘emergent-ness’? Why write books, hold panel discussions, or attack fellow brothers and sisters in Christ? If this didn’t shake the Father or take Him by surprise, then why invest so much effort to dissuade others who have been supposedly ‘surprised’ by relevant culture and church changes? I have trouble reconciling the logic?
The whole scenario reminds me a bit of Acts 5.





We weren’t supposed to meet in that lobby. We had a room assigned to us; HSC 202. We weren’t supposed to meet until 9 pm, but we chose 6:30 pm instead. The book store was closed, but Doretha pressed into the lobby to look around anyway. This was such a God orchestrated moment! Without a doubt, I’m glad we weren’t where we were supposed to be.
